How minimum wage hike in Michigan could devastate small business and hurt workers
The impact it could have in the state
Ann Arbor, MI – In a landmark decision, the Michigan Supreme Court has ruled to increase the state minimum wage to $12 an hour, affecting approximately 494,000 workers. The decision, hailed as a victory for workers' rights by advocates, comes after years of legal battles dating back to 2018 and has raised concerns about its impact on small businesses, particularly in the restaurant and bar industries.
Please become a supporter here on Substack if you aren’t already. Subscribe for $5 a month. You can quit anytime.
The ruling stipulates that bar and restaurant owners must pay their servers a minimum wage of $12 an hour, a significant shift from the current model where workers often rely on tips to supplement lower hourly wages. This change has sparked a debate about the potential economic consequences for small business owners still recovering from the pandemic.
Economic Impact on Small Businesses
Christopher Douglas, an economist at the University of Michigan, expressed concern over the potential challenges this wage increase poses to small business owners, particularly in the hospitality sector. "This is going to be really tough for the bar and restaurant industry, which is still reeling from the effects of the pandemic," Douglas noted. He emphasized that many establishments are already struggling with rising costs due to inflation, including higher prices for food, supplies, and rent.
The Michigan Restaurant and Lodging Association has also voiced concerns, predicting that 66% of restaurant owners may be forced to lay off employees, reduce operating hours, or even shut down. The association highlighted the thin profit margins in the industry, which could make it difficult for businesses to absorb the additional labor costs without passing them on to consumers.
Potential Consumer Response
The wage increase has also raised questions about consumer behavior, particularly regarding tipping practices. Many patrons may be less inclined to tip at the traditional 15-20% rate if they know servers are receiving a higher base wage. A social media user commented, "I'm not going to tip my normal 20% if I know they are getting paid more per hour; I might go down to 3 to 5%, maybe less."
Douglas pointed out that while the wage increase aims to improve workers' earnings, it could inadvertently lead to lower overall compensation if consumers adjust their tipping habits. "Bar and restaurant workers might not see a wage increase and might actually see a decrease if $12 an hour is less than what they currently earn with tips," he explained.
Calls for Legislative Action
In light of the potential economic ramifications, some industry leaders are calling for legislative intervention to find a balanced solution that safeguards both workers' livelihoods and the survival of local businesses. "There needs to be some sort of study that looks at how much these servers make, factoring in tips," Douglas suggested, emphasizing the importance of considering the broader economic context.
Despite the challenges, the decision marks a significant step forward for workers' rights, with supporters arguing that it addresses long-standing inequities in the wage system. "It's a great day for the 494,000 workers who are getting a raise," said a representative from the advocacy group behind the initiative. "We've finally prevailed over corporate interests that tried to prevent fair wages."
As Michigan navigates the implementation of this ruling, the conversation continues about finding the right balance between fair compensation and economic viability for small businesses across the state.